When it’s time to install a new roof, one of the biggest decisions you’ll face is choosing the right roofing material.
Metal and asphalt shingles are two of the most popular options, but which one provides the best value for your investment?
At Roofers Worcester, we’ve installed both metal and asphalt roofs for years, and we know that each has its own advantages and drawbacks.
In this guide, I’ll compare cost, durability, energy efficiency, maintenance, and overall value to help you decide which roofing material is best for your home.
Cost Comparison: Upfront vs. Long-Term Expenses
Asphalt Roofing:
✅ Lower initial cost – Typically costs £5,000 – £10,000 for an average-sized home.
✅ Affordable materials and installation – Asphalt shingles are widely available and easy to install, making labor costs lower.
❌ Higher long-term costs – Asphalt shingles last 15-30 years, meaning you may need a replacement sooner than a metal roof.
Metal Roofing:
✅ Higher upfront cost, but longer lifespan – Costs £8,000 – £20,000, but lasts 40-70 years.
✅ Potential long-term savings – Fewer replacements mean lower costs over time.
❌ Higher installation costs – Metal roofs require skilled labor, which increases installation expenses.
✔ Winner (Upfront Cost): Asphalt Roofing
✔ Winner (Long-Term Value): Metal Roofing
Durability & Lifespan: Which Roof Lasts Longer?
Asphalt Roofing:
✔ Lifespan: 15-30 years, depending on weather conditions and maintenance.
✔ Withstands moderate weather conditions, but can suffer from wind, hail, and extreme temperatures.
❌ Prone to damage from storms – Shingles can blow off in high winds and may crack in extreme heat.
Metal Roofing:
✔ Lifespan: 40-70 years, significantly longer than asphalt.
✔ Highly resistant to wind, hail, and fire.
✔ Won’t crack, warp, or rot like asphalt.
❌ Denting risk: Some metal roofs can dent from large hail or falling debris, though modern metal roofing is highly durable.
✔ Winner: Metal Roofing – It lasts 2-3 times longer than asphalt and handles extreme weather better.
Energy Efficiency & Insulation: Which Saves More on Energy Bills?
Asphalt Roofing:
✅ Moderate insulation properties, but absorbs heat in the summer.
✅ Can be paired with cool roof coatings to reduce heat absorption.
❌ Not as reflective as metal, which can lead to higher cooling costs in hot climates.
Metal Roofing:
✅ Reflects solar heat, reducing cooling costs by 10-25%.
✅ Can be installed with insulated panels for even better energy efficiency.
✅ Works well with solar panels due to its long lifespan and durability.
✔ Winner: Metal Roofing – Its reflective properties reduce energy bills, especially in warmer climates.
Maintenance & Repairs: Which Roof Requires Less Upkeep?
Asphalt Roofing:
✔ Easier and cheaper to repair – Individual shingles can be replaced without a full reroof.
❌ More frequent maintenance needed – Shingles can curl, crack, or develop moss and algae.
❌ Prone to leaks over time – Flashing and sealants may need frequent reapplication.
Metal Roofing:
✔ Low maintenance – Metal roofs don’t crack, warp, or develop moss.
✔ More resistant to leaks – Fewer seams reduce the chance of water penetration.
❌ Repairs can be costly – While durable, fixing dents or replacing panels is more expensive than replacing a few shingles.
✔ Winner: Metal Roofing – Requires far less maintenance than asphalt shingles.
Aesthetic Appeal & Home Value: Which Looks Better?
Asphalt Roofing:
✔ Available in various colors and styles to match traditional homes.
✔ Blends well with most home designs.
❌ Less unique than metal roofs.
Metal Roofing:
✔ Modern and stylish appearance – Available in standing seam, corrugated, and shingle-like designs.
✔ Increases home resale value – Many buyers prefer metal due to durability.
❌ May not suit every home style – Best for contemporary or farmhouse designs.
✔ Winner: Tie – It depends on personal preference and home style.
Environmental Impact: Which Roof Is More Eco-Friendly?
Asphalt Roofing:
❌ Not easily recyclable – Old shingles often end up in landfills.
❌ Shorter lifespan means more waste over time.
Metal Roofing:
✔ 100% recyclable at the end of its life.
✔ Longer lifespan reduces waste – Less frequent replacements mean fewer materials used.
✔ Winner: Metal Roofing – More sustainable and environmentally friendly.
Final Verdict: Which Roof Offers the Best Value?
✔ Best for Budget-Friendly Homeowners: Asphalt Roofing
✔ Best for Long-Term Savings & Durability: Metal Roofing
Overall Winner: Metal Roofing – While the upfront cost is higher, it lasts longer, saves money on energy bills, and requires less maintenance, making it a better long-term investment.
To Sum Up
If you’re looking for affordability and ease of installation, asphalt roofing is a solid choice. But if you want a long-lasting, energy-efficient, and durable roof, metal roofing is the better value in the long run.
At Roofers Worcester, we specialize in both asphalt and metal roofing. If you’re unsure which one is best for your home, contact us today for expert advice and a free estimate!
FAQs
Which roofing material is better for extreme weather?
Metal roofing is superior for wind, hail, and fire resistance. Asphalt shingles can hold up well but are more prone to damage in severe storms.
Can I install solar panels on both asphalt and metal roofs?
Yes, but metal roofs are better suited for solar panel installation because they last longer and won’t need a replacement as soon as asphalt shingles.
Which roofing type is more cost-effective in the long run?
Metal roofing is more cost-effective over time due to its longer lifespan, energy savings, and minimal maintenance needs.
Still unsure which roof is best for your home? Contact Roofers Worcester today for a free consultation!